Cost of Capital: Curve Whiplash
Bond prices held their bid despite some unwinding of risk aversion trade. The curve saw most of the action flattening 20bps as the front end underperformed as the flight to quality trade was reduced on the Fed’s ability to loosen up the money markets. We identified the yield curve as the focus of bond markets with it reflecting fear in the front end and risk premium in the long end. With the Fed presumably holding the line on the Fed funds rate expect the curve to continue to flatten. If we were to see any disruptions in credit expect the curve to steepen. Since we think next week will be quiet we also expect the curve to trade with a flatter bias. Our 5YR backed to 4.40% this week, shy of our 4.50% target. We will look for further retracing next week and are still buyers at that level, though we think nth could make it to 4.75% on a 50% move off the highs. That being said, look to add on pullbacks but with next week likely to be quiet, investors may be best served by sitting on the side and look for 4.75%, our original retrace target.
Ex Ante Factor: The Intimidator
This week we wanted to turn our attention to the bond market and more specifically the action in the long end of the curve. After putting in a panic low during the BSC hedge fund debacle the long bond is breaking out of the downtrend channel and the 10YR contract appears to be finishing off an impulsive 5 wave advance. Of course, the obvious question becomes, “5 of what”? Regardless of that answer, we should see some consolidation either way but the nature of how we emerge from a pullback is what we are focusing on as it carries big implications for the entire capital market and economy. We have been following this fork on the bond contract and how it handles the upper trend line on a pullback give us insight to the degree and direction of the whole coupon curve.
Dominick has always told me he believes bonds and currencies tend to move in 3s, implying they are more apt to trade in ranges as opposed to longer term trends. “The dollar can’t go to zero,” he says. We have a few theories as to why this is true and while the dollar could be technically worthless, his is the simplest and likeliest answer. Currencies are relative values and interest rates reflect growth rates and inflation premiums which are cyclical. Nominal yields can’t go negative, the bond contract isn’t going to 1000 and the dollar isn’t going to 0. Sure, we could be analyzing the Zimbabwe $ and any other hyper-inflationary situations and call the move a multi-year impulsive or 5 wave trend but even these fat tail situations will eventually correct within a band and be labeled 5 of A or C.
With this said and viewing the current 10YR note pattern as a series of 3s and will thus be interpreting this move as an A or 1 of A with consolidation to be a 2 or B wave. This would make sense as the market digests the recent gains from a V bottom reversal while we await an onslaught of economic data and a Fed meeting on the 9/18. This will be some of the first empirical evidence reported since the credit markets seized up.
Some of the highlights include:
8/27: Existing Home Sales
8/28: FOMC minutes
8/31: Personal Income and Spending, Chicago PMI, Bernanke speech from Jackson Hole
9/4: ISM index
9/5: Fed Beige book, Pending Home Sales
9/6: ISM services
(Red Alert: the first indication to the degree of damage from the credit situation on what has been the most robust sector of the US economy)
9/7: Non-farm payrolls
According to my math, 12 month trailing nominal GDP is growing on average at roughly 4.90% with the last two quarters tracking at an average around 4.25%. We are about to get a glimpse to the magnitude the credit crunch had in an already decelerating economic environment. The reaction from the bond market, and maybe more importantly the yield curve, will provide the window for future economic activity.
The 10YR note yield tracks pretty close to long term GDP growth and is currently yielding 4.62%, an appropriate discount in my opinion. Greenspan’s “conundrum” and Bernanke’s “savings glut” were nonsense. The flattening yield curve and subsequent inversion perfectly predicted that growth rates would fall below cost of funds. If Bernanke is looking at the right indicators he should be massively easing. He must be ignoring the indicators or trying to prove a point. We are looking at Elliott, who is pointing to a potential multi-month ABC rally and at minimum targeting the previous high around 114 and the 2002 highs around 120 on the TY1 can’t be ruled out. The extreme case could put us close to 3% on 10YR yields implying recessionary conditions as “real” growth would be essentially flat.
I fear Bernanke is being haunted by his helicopter speech causing him to be tighter than necessary. Granted he can’t affect the re-pricing of risk premium which is at the core of the current market volatility, but had he been able to better calibrate short term funding costs to ease the obviously deceleration in values of collateral we might not have seen such a rapid de-leveraging of credit. It’s almost like he challenged the bond market by not easing at the last meeting and market decided they would take matters into their own hands. Shutting down the repo and commercial paper markets proved that they could bankrupt major institutions in a matter of days. That is some awesome power.
Clinton advisor, James Carville once said:
“I used to think if there was reincarnation, I wanted to come back as the President or the Pope or a .400 baseball hitter, but now I want to come back as the bond market. You can intimidate everybody.”
Hell yes you can.
What is the discount?
Risk continued to perform well this week with the yield falling on the S&P and medium grade corporate debt 14bps and 8bps respectively. Risk premiums fell across the board but still remain cheap relative to the 2007 average. We think this could continue to support stock prices for the near term but view the 300bps of implied equity premium to be still narrow and would feel better about longer term positions at a spread of 500bps.
| Security |
Yield |
Chg 1 W |
AVG 2007 |
|
SPX Earnings
|
5.75% |
-0.14% |
5.60% |
|
SPX Dividend
|
1.89% |
-0.04% |
1.84% |
|
High Grade Yield
|
6.19% |
0.01% |
6.00% |
|
Interim Grade Yield
|
7.33% |
-0.08% |
6.98% |
|
US 10YR Yield
|
4.62% |
-0.06% |
4.80% |
|
Implied Return
|
7.64% |
-0.18% |
7.44% |
|
Implied Credit RP
|
2.71% |
-0.02% |
2.18% |
|
Implied Equity RP
|
3.02% |
-0.12% |
2.64% |
|
Equity-Debt RP
|
0.31% |
-0.10% |
0.46% |
| Source: Barrons |
Bottom Line: This week all markets traded according to expectations. The dollar retreated as the curve flattened and risk was reapplied. There is not much to say other than we expect this week to be slow and would advise investors to sit tight in their 5YR notes while the amateurs chop themselves up. Post Labor Day should be much more informative and provide guidance for direction